PHOENIX — The Goldwater Institute has filed a lawsuit against the Tolleson Union High School District after district officials demanded $13,000 to provide public records detailing taxpayer-funded expenditures, including payments to a limousine company, country club, amusement park, indoor go-kart facility and casino resorts.
The lawsuit alleges the district violated Arizona’s public records law by refusing to provide electronic copies of financial documents and instead insisting on charging $1 per page for printed records.
The dispute began in March when the Goldwater Institute requested the district’s purchase orders for the 2024-25 fiscal year. According to the organization, district officials refused to release the documents electronically and demanded approximately $13,000 to produce paper copies.
District Superintendent Jeremy Calles defended the district’s position, reportedly stating that the district doesn’t “gift electricity for witch hunts.”
In August, Goldwater narrowed its request to supporting documentation for 37 expenditures it identified as questionable. The district again declined to provide the records electronically, prompting the organization to pursue legal action.
According to financial records obtained by the Goldwater Institute, the district’s expenditures included:
- $35,400 for advertising.
- $32,930 for employee coaching and leadership development.
- $15,670.84 paid to a limousine company.
- $6,320.97 paid to Arrowhead Country Club in Glendale.
- $2,635 spent at Knott’s Berry Farm, a California amusement park.
- $1,514.94 spent at Andretti Indoor Karting and Games.
- Additional travel-related charges at Casino Del Sol and Meritage Resort.
While the expenditures appear in the district’s financial records, Goldwater argues that the available information does not adequately explain the purpose of the payments or how they relate to the district’s educational mission.
The lawsuit does not establish that the expenditures were improper. Rather, Goldwater is seeking access to the underlying invoices, receipts and purchase orders to determine how taxpayer funds were used.
The organization maintains that Arizona’s public records law guarantees access to government documents and that public agencies cannot impose unreasonable fees that effectively prevent taxpayers from examining financial records.
Goldwater has partnered with attorney Greg Iannelli of its American Freedom Network, a network of pro bono attorneys, to challenge the district’s refusal to provide the requested documents electronically.
“Public records belong to the public, not to district administrators,” Iannelli said. “A five-figure bill for receipts the district already has isn’t a fee—it’s a wall. The law doesn’t allow for it, and we’re asking the court to take it down.”
Goldwater contends that the district already maintains the requested records electronically, making the requirement to print thousands of pages unnecessary.
“These records exist electronically, and that’s how we asked to receive them,” said Stacy Skankey, the Goldwater Institute’s American Freedom Network Litigation Director. “There is no reason to print them out, charge $1 a page, and put them in the mail. We sent the same request to another school district at the same time, and that district delivered its records promptly, electronically, and for free. Tolleson’s fees are not a cost of doing business. They’re a tactic to deny access.”
The organization argues that allowing government agencies to impose substantial fees for records already available electronically could establish a precedent that limits public oversight of taxpayer spending throughout Arizona.
Under Arizona law, public records are generally available for inspection, although agencies may impose certain authorized fees for copies. Goldwater’s lawsuit challenges whether the district’s proposed charges and refusal to provide electronic records comply with those requirements.
The case seeks judicial intervention to require the Tolleson Union High School District to provide access to the requested financial documents without what Goldwater characterizes as unreasonable fees.
The district’s response to the lawsuit and its explanations for the expenditures were not included in the information provided.

Be the first to comment