Trial Of Dad Who Killed 5-Year-Old Son Can Move Forward

The Arizona Supreme Court’s ruling has upheld the Court of Appeals opinion in State v. Martinson, the case of a father, Jeffrey Martinson, accused of killing his five-year-old son in 2004. The ruling allowing the Maricopa County Attorney’s Office to resume prosecution of Martinson.

In August 2004, Martinson, a divorced father, had a scheduled weekend visitation with his son. When victim was not returned on Sunday evening, his mother called police to check on Martinson’s home. Once there, police discovered the defendant lying on his bed, unresponsive, with his wrists cut. In another room they found the five-year-old boy deceased. A toxicology report later found evidence of a lethal amount of muscle relaxant in the child’s blood. The defendant was indicted by a grand jury of one count of first degree felony murder and one count of child abuse.

The case went to trial in 2011, and after opening statements, the defense made a motion to preclude evidence of intent to kill, which the Superior Court granted erroneously relying on a 1993 case, State v. Styers. Though jurors unanimously found the defendant guilty of both counts, they were unable to reach a unanimous decision in the penalty phase, resulting in a mistrial.

The defense made a motion for a new trial, citing juror misconduct and other errors. The trial judge granted this motion. In order to ensure that evidence of intent would be admissible, the State subsequently filed new charges in 2012 for premeditated murder and asked that the newer charges be substituted for the older ones. This request was litigated between the trial court and the appellate courts, with the trial court ultimately dismissing the 2004 case with prejudice–in effect barring any prosecution whatsoever. The Court of Appeals’ ruling, which has been upheld, found that the trial court ruled in error and allows the prosecution of Martinson to resume.

About ADI Staff Reporter 16202 Articles
Under the leadership of Editor-in -Chief Huey Freeman, our team of staff reporters bring accurate,timely, and complete news coverage.