Arizona Senators Join Razor-Thin Majority To OK Health Care Debate

Sen. John McCain, R-Arizona, voted to let debate proceed on plans to repeal or replace Obamacare. But McCain said he could not vote for any current bills without heavy amendment. (Photo by Ben Moffat/Cronkite News)

By Brianna Stearns

WASHINGTON – Both Arizona senators joined the majority of their fellow Republicans and voted by the narrowest possible margin Tuesday to allow debate on measures that could repeal or replace the Affordable Care Act.

The 51-50 vote marked the emotional return of Sen. John McCain, R-Arizona, who said he could not vote for the “shell of a bill” before the Senate, but that he wanted debate to move forward.

McCain, diagnosed last week with an aggressive form of brain cancer, reminded senators of their responsibility to work together, something he said did not happen when Democrats passed Obamacare or when Republicans tried to replace it.

“Merely preventing your political opponents from doing what they want isn’t the most inspiring work,” McCain said to his fellow senators. “There’s greater satisfaction in respecting our differences, but not letting them prevent agreements that don’t require abandonment of core principles, agreements made in good faith that help improve lives and protect the American people.”

McCain said he had amendments proposed by Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey “that will have to be included for my support of final passage of any bill.”

Ducey’s office did not return requests for comment Tuesday. But he has expressed concern in the past about the cost states would have to bear – the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System estimated that previous versions of the bill could cost the state up to $7.1 billion over 10 years – and the possible loss of coverage to hundreds of thousands of Arizonans.

The Senate vote came just hours after mayors of Phoenix and Mesa joined others on a conference call urging Congress to take a step back and “start from scratch” on health care reform.

Phoenix Mayor Greg Stanton, a Democrat, said the current House and Senate proposals “would be a disaster for our state,” leaving thousands uninsured. Mesa Mayor John Giles, a Republican, said he agreed that the ACA, better known as Obamacare, is flawed.

“I think that everyone agrees that we want to improve it, but the way to fix something is not to make it worse,” Giles said Tuesday. “And I’m afraid that’s the options being debated right now in Washington, D.C.”

Tuesday’s Senate vote follows weeks of wrangling by Senate Republicans trying to craft a bill that pleases both wings of the party. They can only afford to lose a few GOP votes in the face of Democratic opposition, with all 48 Democrats in the Senate uniformly opposed to the Republicans’ repeal or replacement bills.

The Congressional Budget Office estimated that a bill passed by the House in May could cost 23 million people their health coverage by 2026, while reducing the federal deficit by $119 billion. A proposed Senate bill would have pushed 22 million people off health coverage and it would have cut the deficit by $321 billion, according to the CBO.

That bill was pulled when Republican leaders in the Senate realized they did not have the votes for it. In its place, they offered a bill to repeal the ACA, better known as Obamacare, that passed in 2015 but was vetoed by then-President Barack Obama.

But that plan ran into opposition when the CBO reported that repeal without replacement could cost 32 million Americans their coverage, while reducing the federal deficit by $473 billion.

That led to Tuesday’s procedural vote to allow debate to proceed on the House version of the bill. It needed only a simple majority, but Vice President Mike Pence had to vote to break a 50-50 tie after Republican Sens. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Susan Collins of Maine voted no.

Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Arizona, like many who voted yes Tuesday, said he supported the motion because it will allow for “an open, transparent, and thorough debate process to best deal with repealing Obamacare.”

“Obamacare is failing and I look forward to considering various solutions to ensure Arizonans have access to affordable, quality health care,” Flake said in a statement released by his office.

Giles last week, after the failure of a previous Senate bill, called on Senate leaders to change their approach when drafting the next proposals, saying it “should be done in an inclusive, open manner.”

“I hope that Sens. McCain and Flake and their colleagues will take mayors up on our offer to partner to craft bipartisan legislation that meets the needs of cities and towns across Arizona,” Giles said then.


  1. Single payer health care, free college, food stamps for all, lifetime welfare. Ask not what you can do for your country, but ask what can your country do for you.

  2. Its not about the ACA and never has been. The democrats knew that it would crash and burn and it is. Its about a one payer system pure and simple. Medicare for all. If you think that works for us all, you are sadly mistaken but that is what the democrats want in the final version. Schumer even so much has said it. If it does happen, then our medical system which is now controlled by insurance companies will collapse under its own weight. We will spend over half of our GDP on insurance and the taxes will have to rise to pay for it. If they don’t we will be broke. Oh, wait, we already are aren’t we. How nice.

    • The only problem was the Democrats ran the most corrupt politician in the history of this great country, and the voters rejected her and the Progressive ideology they espouse. Their plan for single-payer got short circuited. Oh well,let it die on the vine.

    • JD you are 100% correct in that statement regarding ‘single payer’ – which were words I heard directly from the mouth of Pete Stark House Ways and Means (CMS) director some 8+ years back when they enacted competitive bidding for medicare providers. The results of that program has medicare providers down by 40%, no one wants to deal with the system, Medicare is a joke – unsustainable and also in collapse because of this single payer mind set they have implanted via Obamacare.

  3. VS a mandatory tax – buying agenda driven medicine – supporting elements of lifestyle and choice that simply are against personal belief – by mandate – is not medicine, it’s control. I’m sure there is a middle ground that can be found.. but that has been the problem, those doing the agenda driving want it ‘their way’ without choice, they say they know better of what you should be doing, or else. NYET! Must be the Russians.. BTW – love your brother of of high commandment, healing is one of those forms.

Comments are closed.