Flake, Kyl join razor-thin majority to put Kavanaugh on Supreme Court

By Alexis Egeland

WASHINGTON – Arizona Sens. Jeff Flake and Jon Kyl fell in line with other Senate Republicans Saturday to confirm Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination to the Supreme Court by the narrowest of margins.

The 50-48 vote was partisan, expected and mostly anticlimactic after weeks of emotional and bitter fights over the nomination that was roiled by decades-old charges of sexual assault against Kavanaugh, and his strident denials and partisan attacks on his accusers.

Within hours of the 3:30 p.m. EDT vote, President Donald Trump had signed the commission of appointment for Kavanaugh and he was sworn in at the Supreme Court, where chanting protesters crowded the steps. Now-Justice Kavanaugh is expected to “participate in the work of the court immediately,” according to a statement from the Supreme Court’s press office.

While Kyl and Flake voted without comment, protesters were not so quiet Saturday.

The vote to approve Kavanaugh was interrupted several times by people shouting in the galleries. Outside the Capitol, scores of protesters were arrested when they crossed police barriers and walked up the front steps of the building. A crowd of hundreds later cheered as each of the people arrested was led away in cuffs.

Across the street, protesters also gathered at the closed Supreme Court and stormed the front steps after Kavanaugh was approved. They carried signs saying they believed survivors and would remember in November at the ballot box.

President Donald Trump dismissed the number of protesters Saturday, saying they all “could sit in the second row” of the rally he was headed to in Topeka, Kansas, last night.

More coverage

Read previous coverage to see how Brett Kavanaugh’s Supreme Court nomination unfolded

“I very much appreciate those 50 great votes” to confirm Kavanaugh’s nomination, Trump said, according to a White House pool report. “And I think he’s going to go down as a totally brilliant Supreme Court justice for many years.”

The 50-48 vote split almost entirely along party lines, with every Democrat but West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin voting against Kavanaugh. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, initially voted no but then changed her vote to “present” as a favor to Sen. Steve Daines, R-Montana, who was home for his daughter’s wedding and could not cast a vote.

Murkowski’s switch did not affect the final outcome.

Murkowski and Manchin were two of a handful of senators – along with Flake – who were closely watched as potential swing votes in the Senate, where Republicans hold just a one-vote majority.

Flake had been a solid supporter of Kavanaugh’s until recent weeks, when allegations of sexual assault came up. Flake said then that he would have difficulty voting for Kavanaugh without first hearing from his accuser, Christine Blasey Ford.

It was at that hearing nine days ago where Ford testified that a drunken Kavanaugh had pinned her to a bed and attempted to take her clothes off, at one point putting his hand over her mouth, when they were both teenagers at a party in suburban Maryland in 1982.

Kavanaugh, who was subsequently accused by other women, followed Ford’s testimony with a heated, partisan defense in which he accused Democrats of orchestrating a political hit on him, and was argumentative with Democrats who tried to question him.

Flake said then that he found Ford credible and Kavanaugh convincing, but planned to vote for Kavanaugh because he should enjoy a presumption of innocence. But after a heated Judiciary Committee meeting, a clearly pained Flake orchestrated a delay in the nomination to allow for a focused FBI investigation of the accusations.

Even then, Flake said he was a conservative and hoped to see Kavanaugh, a conservative judge, on the high court.

Protester arrests were largely orderly and peaceful outside the Capitol on Saturday. (Photo by Cronkite News)

In the intervening week, Flake said he was concerned by Kavanaugh’s demeanor in the last hearing, but wanted to wait for the FBI report.

That report was delivered Thursday – but only seen by senators. Democrats claimed it had been too limited in scope, while Republicans said it turned up nothing to corroborate Ford’s charges.

Kyl took to the Senate floor Thursday to announce his support for Kavanaugh – hardly surprising, since before being named to fill the late Sen. John McCain’s seat, Kyl had been tapped by the White House to shepherd Kavanaugh’s nomination through the Senate.

“Having sat through over 50 interviews, heard the questions asked of him and his responses … I really believe I’ve got a very good idea of how he would conduct himself as an associate justice on the U.S. Supreme Court,” Kyl said Thursday. “That, after all … is the most important question before us.”

Flake made no official statement until his vote Saturday. His office was locked Friday and Flake, after being cornered by reporters as he tried to get into a car at the Capitol, gave a reluctant confirmation that he would vote yes, “unless something big changed” before Saturday’s vote.

“This is a tough decision, obviously,” he says on posted videos of the encounter. “This is a difficult decision for everybody, it really is. So, anyway, we did our best.”

About Cronkite News 2273 Articles
Cronkite News is the news division of Arizona PBS. The daily news products are produced by the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University.


  1. We shouldn’t worry about what Jeffy will do after his term. He’ll end up like they all do, with some other cushy job in D.C.

  2. A razor thin majority, but still a majority thanks to Harry Reid and the dems with their shenanigans. What goes around, comes back to bite you.

  3. Let’s just hope his replacement is better, but I’m not holding my breath. I don’t like, or trust, either of them!

  4. maybe the thought that he has to go some to somewhere when he’s done and make a living is starting to take note in his mind… when this is over where do I go? I think Arizona is going to be a tough place for him to live.

    • I expect he will be looking for an appointment to an office or he will be running for an office at the end of his term. Like a bad penny we won’t be seeing the last of him.

      • You gotta know it. He’s got a taste of the limelight and is liking it a lot. Why else would he be mugging every opportunity that’s presented? I still say he is campaigning for something without actually campaigning. Why spend good money when you can create a fuss over something and get plenty of air-time just by being a putz? He seems to have the suck-up role down pat. I just hope is isn’t in Arizona.

  5. He foolishly started his term on the gang of 8 but ended it by voting to confirm a conservative SCJ. The Kavanaugh vote might be the 1st time he did something i agreed with.

Comments are closed.