I Fought The Law And I Won

Pima County Sheriff Department tactical training exercise.

In 2013 due to a 911 call, The Pima County Sheriff’s Department ordered my wife and I out of our home at gun point, we were handcuffed and marched into the street, detained and questioned. Our house was searched without a warrant. Then when the 911 caller was finally contacted, the caller stated that if it wasn’t our house, then it must be our neighbor’s house, so the Pima County Sheriff’s Department proceeded to raid their house as well. When the raids were completed and no evidence of domestic violence was found, the Pima County Sheriff’s Department realized that the caller had mental issues and was making all of this up, 12 deputies were involved in these raids.

There are a lot of Why’s in this case, but the Why’s are not what this story is about.

We filed a law suit in Federal Court against the Pima County Sheriff’s Department for illegal search and seizure which is a Fourth Amendment violation and guess what “WE WON” . The jury awarded damages in our case, but at this time the Pima County Sheriff’s Department is appealing the ruling to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

What I really want to tell everyone is Why we won our case.

It all started with being ordered out of our house at gun point, when I came to the door in my underwear, I found that we had three deputies all aiming their firearms at us, 2 of them had assault rifles and 1 had his service pistol. I knew that I had done nothing wrong, but because of these deputies’ attitude, we were in fear that our lives would be taken if we had made any kind of wrong move. We obeyed every order we were given, we did not argue or complain about what was happening in fear that this would set the deputies off and they would start shooting. Yes we were in shock of what was happening to us and still suffer from it today. BUT. Because we had done nothing wrong and because we did not give the deputies any reason to start shooting, we were able to survive this experience and take the Pima County Sheriff’s Department to court to protest the actions against us.

If you feel like your rights are being violated by members of any law enforcement organization (LEO), don’t argue, don’t fight, don’t run and don’t make it difficult for LEO to do what they perceive to be their job. Your first job is to survive the encounter and you can do this by following the instructions above.

When it is all over, then you can gather the facts and file a complaint.

It took 3 years for our case to get to court and now it may be another year before the Appeals Court hears our case and if for some reason we lose the appeal, we are prepared to take it the Supreme Court.

If you do everything right and survive your encounter, you will get your day in court to prove that you were wronged.

I hope that the Pima County Sheriff Department will change their policies and procedures to align with the Constitutional protections that we were given.

If you want to protest an action or a law, do it the right way “Take them to court”, don’t block traffic or make a nuisance out of yourself.

Law Enforcement Organizations has a very tough job and we give LEO the responsibility to enforce our laws up to and including taking a life to ensure the protection of us as citizens.

However, when LEO violates our rights, they need to held accountable to the highest standards of the law because of the rights and abilities they are given.

We as tax paying citizens invest a lot of money in our Law Enforcement Officers to insure that they have the proper training and equipment to protect us and themselves. Because of this investment and the responsibilities that we give these officers, anyone who harms these officers also need to held accountable to the highest standards of the law.

The United States of America is nation that was founded on Rule of Law and these laws can be found in the Constitution of the United States of America. Everyone should be subjected to follow these laws.

Our Judicial system was set up to handle cases like ours and many others, so don’t feel like you need to take the law into your hands. Let the courts decide. It worked for me and should work for everyone.

I fought the law (The right way) and I won!

Related Article:

Pima County Sheriff Department “Standard Operating Procedures” questioned

About Rob Larson 7 Articles
Rob Larson is a southern Arizona businessman, who is also an expert on firearm safety. He is the director of the Tucson Trap and Skeet Club.


  1. Taxpayer
    Yes there is a history on this caller, The sheriff’s dept had even transported him to a metal health facility for evaluation because he told them he was hearing voices (This happened less then a month before he made this call), He had also made threats to shoot any LEO that came on his property
    No there has not been any charges filed against him

  2. So what happened to the caller?
    Charges for false report?

    Was there “history” on the caller to
    give pause to those “triggering” the
    Law Enforcement response?
    These are questions which may have been
    broached in Court but not mentioned in the

  3. I hope that policies within the department have changed for the better and that the courts award the Larson family justly.

  4. This is important and sensible information.never argue with men with guns. Look for safety and then absolutely look for your due process and Sue them. I am sure this incident has caused significant trauma to the writer and his wife. I don’t understand why a call to them or a knock on the door before going Rambo wouldn’t have been a more prudent first step assessment.

  5. It should not go unnoticed that ACTING SHERIFF NANOS was actually the one in charge during this time as “Sheriff” DOPENIK was spending most of his time in San Diego.


  6. Great advice and kudos to Mr. Larson for taking the time to pass it on. Billy has a point but I respectfully disagree that blame should be put on the rank and file personnel. There is a Dispatcher, a Captain or Supervisor or whatever title is used for the person or persons that screwed up and ordered this team to go in “hot” to this bogus call without any proper due diligence. They are the responsible party. Maybe a visit to the “nut job” caller that reported the domestic first to verify the information given might have been a good idea. As far as how the Larson’s were treated on this call, all it would have taken was for whomever the team leader was to first assess and then say: Let them get their clothes on, or don’t treat them like that and for Gods sake don’t point your guns at them, THEY”RE CUFFED AND BAREFOOT! Especially if they did not witness a crime being committed! However, I do know domestic violence calls are one of the most dangerous calls. Hypocritically speaking, had this been one of my daughters being hurt this is the team I would have wanted to respond…

    • It is stories like this that make me leave shoes, a flashlight, and night clothes by side of the bed.

  7. The LEOs and their superiors that ordered them to violate the plaintiff’s rights won’t be paying the money awarded. The poor old taxpayers will be paying for the payout and that’s wrong. Government employees, including LEOs, need to be personally held liable when they knowingly violate civil rights or make grievous errors such as the EPA people that trashed the Animas River. The LEOs knew what they were doing wasn’t right. Hold these officers personally legally and financially responsible for violating civil rights and they will be questioning wrongful orders in a flash.

    For the record, I’m a big supporter of law enforcement but the law works both ways.

    • Amen I couldn’t agree more. Unfortunately the personal responsibility has been Destroyed by Lawyers.

  8. in the meantime these same officers are on the street – the ones you feared would be set off and take your life. That is wrong.

Comments are closed.