Clean Energy Ballot Initiative Could Take Palo Verde Nuclear Plant Off The Grid

The Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station occupies about 4,000 acres in Tonopah, Arizona. (Photo by Jenna Miller/Cronkite News)

By Faith Miller

TONOPAH — About 50 miles west of downtown Phoenix, three massive concrete domes, spaced side-by-side on a 4,000-acre plot of land, dominate the skyline.

The Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station is the nation’s largest power producer, serving 4 million peopleacross the Southwest and providing about 35 percent of Arizona’s electric power, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Palo Verde relies on billions of gallons of recycled wastewater each year for cooling.

If the Clean Energy for a Healthy Arizona initiative appears on the ballot in November, voters will decide the plant’s future. The initiative calls for 50 percent of Arizona’s electrical energy to come from renewable sources, mostly solar and wind, by 2030. Nuclear power would be hit hardest among sources of power in Arizona, because Palo Verde – the nation’s largest power producer – could not operate at levels low enough to satisfy the initiative’s requirements. Supporters have less than two months to gather enough signatures to qualify.

Linnea Conway and Jackie Sullivan (left) check gear as workers leave. Scanners tell the two women if there are any radioactive particles on items leaving the building. (Photo by Jenna Miller/ Cronkite News)

At a news media tour of the plant in April, reporters donned head-to-toe protective gear to guard against radiation before entering one of Palo Verde’s three nuclear-containment buildings. The reactor was undergoing refueling, a process that repeats every 18 months.

Inside the sweltering concrete dome, a central pool containing the nuclear reactor gave off a bluish tinge. The jumpsuit-clad refueling crew sat aboard a metal contraption moving slowly above the pool, dragging fuel assemblies – rectangular stacks of pallets containing uranium – by a rope through the water.

Every six months, one of the containment buildings goes through a monthlong refueling process. Palo Verde plans these outages for the fall and spring, when Arizona and Southern California need the least electricity for heating and cooling, spokesman Alan Bunnell said. Turning the reactor on and off isn’t as easy as pressing a button – it involves weeks of preparation.

That’s one of the reasons the plant would have to shut down completely if the ballot initiative passes, said Jack Cadogan, senior vice president of site operations. Solar energy sources would generate so much power during the day in Arizona that there wouldn’t be enough room on the grid for nuclear.

“We would have to shut Palo Verde down during the day every day,” Cadogan said. “But that’s not how nuclear plants really work. Nuclear plants can’t just be shut down and then started up again.”

Kack Cadogan, senior vice president of site operations at Palo Verde nuclear power plant, said he is worried that a potential referendum on clean energy in Arizona would threaten the future of the plant. (Photo by Jenna Miller/ Cronkite News)

California has a similar problem, he said. Its solar energy sources produce so much excess electricity that it pays Arizona to take the excess power. But if Arizona must switch to 50 percent renewables, it no longer will be able to take California’s extra power. That means both states probably will have to spend billions developing technology to store solar energy, he said.

“The only reason (California’s) electric bills are not double of ours, I think, is because they have not tackled the storage issue,” Cadogan said. “But this mandate would force us all to tackle it all at once. And there’s going to be a lot of customers that are going to be hurt, especially lower income customers.”

Supporters of the initiative, including Sandy Bahr of the Sierra Club’s Grand Canyon chapter, argue that the long-term benefits outweigh the immediate costs.

“Here in Arizona, solar is a great resource that we have that we should be utilizing more of,” Bahr said. “And I think the public gets that, the voters get that, and they’re very supportive of it. That’s why the utilities are trying so hard to create confusion and to create fear and try and undermine it.”

Because generating nuclear energy produces radioactive waste and involves mining and processing uranium, a nonrenewable resource, nuclear isn’t classified as renewable. However, APS calls the Palo Verde plant the nation’s largest source of clean-air energy because it doesn’t emit carbon.

For the initiative’s backers, though, that’s not enough.

“From the perspective of someone who wants clean, sustainable, renewable energy, nuclear power doesn’t cut it,” Bahr said.

Supporters of the Clean Energy initiative must get nearly 226,000 signatures by July 5 to get it on the November ballot. Backers include the Arizona Asthma Coalition and the Natural Resources Defense Council.


– Cronkite News video by Nicole Hernandez

This story is part of Elemental: Covering Sustainability, a new multimedia collaboration between Cronkite News, Arizona PBS, KJZZ, KPCC, Rocky Mountain PBS and PBS SoCal.

10 Comments on "Clean Energy Ballot Initiative Could Take Palo Verde Nuclear Plant Off The Grid"

  1. Solar will never be able to replace the Palo Verde Nuclear Plant. Solar heats up the environment and can cook birds in flight. Turn off 35% and the party is over. Vote No in November!

  2. What, Again | May 16, 2018 at 4:48 am | Reply

    The real issue with white men destroying the climate is air conditioning. Ban it in Arizona. Humans have no right to be living in the desert with conditioned air. They should be forced, by law, to live in a ‘sustainable’ environment.

    • Not to mention things like water treatment facilities. Look at all the chemicals and power used for nothing other than clean healthy water. Most people on the planet live without clean water and we could do it too. Another thing.. hospitals. They use massive amounts of power just to keep people alive. Why? There is no shortage of people. If people really cared about the environment they would find a nice tree or cactus and sit beside it and turn themselves into fertilizer. You should follow your dreams, What, Again, and rejoin the carbon chain. Be one with nature. Be nature.

      Bless Gaia, Ommmm Ommmm

    • What the hell is with the “white men” when there are less white men in Arizona the “tan men” that work in construction of homes and business. True colors are coming out – you racist!

      • What, Again | May 16, 2018 at 6:09 pm | Reply

        Has nothing to do that white men ARE a minority, as you proclaim. It’s that the entirety of the ‘environmental’, ‘progressive’ actions is hate against white men, the symbol of capitalism, success and America. If you can’t see that ‘sustainable’ is nothing more than communism infers you are a fool.

  3. Pop ups in the middle of the screen do not make me feel warm and fuzzy. Try something else.

  4. The Oracle of Tucson | May 16, 2018 at 7:47 pm | Reply

    While I realize that agenda driven Cronkite news is consistently fake news disguised as real news, I couldn’t help but notice that none of Sandy Bahr’s credentials were listed as being an expert on modern energy production.
    I’m just gonna go out on a limb and say Sandy Bahr of the Sierra Club’s Grand Canyon chapter is just another ignorent self destructive environmental wack job who thinks she and her wacky birds of a feather friends know what best for the rest of us no matter the cost.
    Maybe Sandy should consider moving to loonyville Portland or Seattle to be among friends.
    I won’t be voting in favor of this idiotic idea and would encourage anyone with a brain to do the same.
    A lot of time, effort and money went into getting the Palo Verde plant built in the first place, with its monsterous potential for clean energy, what a tragic waste to let it be closed by tree hugging hysteria.

    The Oracle

  5. I have a bright idea to save the environment! Let’s raise the electric rates to the point that humans can’t afford to live here. The Gila monsters and scorpions will be so happy to roam free.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*