Spark From Machinery Caused Museum Fire, No Negligence Found

museum fire
Museum Fire [Photo courtesy Coconino County]

FLAGSTAFF – On Friday, the U.S. Forest Service announced the preliminary results of the investigation into the cause of the Museum Fire. The human-caused wildfire began July 21, and burned 1,961 acres on the Coconino National Forest above Flagstaff.

According to the U.S. Forest Service report, fire investigators have determined that the fire started during a thinning operation “in a steep slope environment and was likely caused by an excavator striking a rock during operations. The resulting spark created a heat source that hibernated until warm, dry, and windy conditions arrived that caused the heat source to grow into a small fire and was subsequently spread by the wind. Rock strikes are possible during operations in steep slope thinning restoration projects such as the Flagstaff Watershed Protection Project.”

The Forest Service does not believe the fire was related to negligence. The Service found that all proper inspections of equipment were conducted.

“The investigation also determined that the last piece of equipment was used 14 hours prior to the first report of fire, and the operator had completed a one-hour fire watch before leaving the area.”

“It’s unfortunate that the Museum Fire started as the result of ongoing restoration work designed to reduce the risk of uncharacteristic wildfire and improve forest health and resiliency—especially in the Flagstaff area where citizens joined together to invest resources to help fund the Flagstaff Watershed Protection Project,” said Coconino National Forest Supervisor Laura Jo West in a press release. “Fortunately, some of the restoration work that had been completed previously in and around the wildfire area actually helped stop the fire from becoming larger and more destructive.”

“Post-fire analysis show that 50 percent of the wildfire burned at low severity, 38 percent burned at moderate severity, and 12 percent of the area burned at high severity. During the past several years, city and Coconino National Forest personnel have worked diligently to implement planned Flagstaff Watershed Protection Project actions and have made substantial progress.”

“In 2014, Flagstaff voters approved a $10 million bond to thin local forests in order to protect valuable watershed and to reduce catastrophic wildfires and their flooding aftermath,” said Arizona State Rep. Bob Thorpe. “Northern Arizona has 10 to 20 times denser forests than a century ago, so the Forest thinning projects are crucial for restoring historic forest health, protecting northern Arizona communities and our natural resources. As a former firefighter, I know that heavy equipment, like tracked vehicles including bulldozers, can cause sparks just by traveling across rock and gravel. Even a horse’s steel horseshoes can cause these same sparks. I’m very pleased that the thinning is occurring, and I do not blame the logging crews for the recent Museum Fire. However, I am profoundly grateful to the quick response of the local, state and federal fire crews in quickly containing the fire, and Coconino County’s emergency response personnel in preparing for the potential for post-fire flooding. The 15,000 acre Shultz Fire taught us a valuable lesson, it wasn’t the fire that did the greatest harm to our communities, but mere weeks later after the fire was out the 2010 Monsoon caused one death and millions of dollars in flood damage.”

“While the cause of the fire is unfortunate, it does not take away from the significant mitigating impact the treatment work had on the fire and subsequently the forest and our watershed,” said Flagstaff Mayor Coral Evans. “The restoration work initiated by the Flagstaff Watershed Protection Project, in partnership with the Forest Service, is incredibly valuable and we remain committed to continuing this work and further protecting our watershed.”

“Deep layers of forest fuels and roots can hold heat for long periods of time, burning and smoldering underground for days, weeks, or months without any sign of a fire. They can surface at a later time when temperatures become warmer and the weather becomes windier, causing a wildfire.”

The Forest Service will continue the investigation.

 

1 Comment

Comments are closed.